1885 High Wall or 1874 Sharps?

[Ed333]

Thanks Cody. I did not make clear in my first post that I was not looking to get into black powder right off, although that is a distinct possibility, there is some BPCR shooting going on in Maine, and even on occasion at my own club. I figure on playing around with smokeless reloading at first, I may get to black powder. But that does not affect any of your advice. I will say that I have had my eye open for a Winchester BPCR for some time, and simply have not seen one become available. I have missed on a couple of Brownings in the past, just was not ready to make the jump. I will also comment (not from any personal knowledge, but from reading) that many people seem to be happy with the accuracy they get from Uberti's, but I don't know from experience yet. More compelling at the moment, I am ready to spend somewhere a little north of a grand right now, but not three grand.